HIV Reporting
2004 – Bristol-Myers Squibb
Company
Whereas:
Investors have an interest in
how our company balances long-term issues with shorter-term performance;
One long-term factor relevant
to our company is the public health crisis confronting emerging markets and its
implications for the future sustainability of our company's sector's current
business model;
There are more than 42 million
people worldwide currently living with HIV/AIDS, over 95% of whom live in the
developing world;
Effective treatments for
HIV/AIDS exist, but only 4% of those who need treatment have access to it;
According to UNAIDS, the
HIV/AIDS pandemic is "creating or aggravating poverty among millions of
people, eroding human capital, weakening government institutions and
threatening business activities and investment";
MALARIA kills between one and
two million people each year and 300-500 million new cases occur every year;
Malaria is often treated in
developing countries with drugs that are no longer effective, and people with
resistant malaria cannot access the treatment that could save their lives;
In a report for the UN
Conference on Financing for Development, UNAIDS states: "Increasing
illness and death of large numbers of productive members of society will reduce
overall production and consumption";
The highly touted agreement at
the World Trade Organization related to easing access to essential medicines in
developing countries has several riders. They place new regulatory burdens and
additional uncertainty on countries and companies importing and exporting generic
essential medicines.
Core Ratings, a subsidiary of
Fitch Ratings, first recognized as a nationally recognized statistical rating
organization (NRSRO) by the SEC in 1975, has found, relative to our company's
peers in the pharmaceutical industry, that our company's "public
disclosure is good in terms of written and published information. However, the company demonstrates a
reticence to discuss issues beyond what it has published." It further reports that "Merck does not
disclose its position on patent flexibility or give examples of where it has
relaxed patents to improve access in developing countries." (Philanthropy
or Good Business? Emerging Market Issues for the Global Pharmaceutical
Industry, Core Ratings, May 2003).
The World Bank reports that in southern
Africa and other affected regions "a complete economic collapse will
occur" unless there is a response to the HIV/AIDS pandemic. Even "a
delay in responding to the outbreak of the epidemic, however, can lead to
collapse." (The Long-run Economic Costs of AIDS, June 2003, The World
Bank).
RESOLVED: Shareholders request
that our Board review the economic effects of the HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and
malaria pandemics on the company's business strategy, and its initiatives to
date, and report to shareholders within six (6) months following the 2004
annual meeting. This report, developed at reasonable costs and omitting
proprietary information, will identify the impacts of these pandemics on the
company.
Supporting Statement:
Investors want to feel confident
that our board has fully considered the risks and opportunities our company
faces in relation to the public health crisis in emerging markets, and has
effective policies and processes in place for dealing with the challenges.
Sponsors:
Lead: Society of Jesus -- Detroit Province, Doris
Gormley SRI Consultant; ASC Investment
Group; Benedictine Srs. of Mt. Angel; Congregation of the Sisters of St. Joseph
of Peace, St. Joseph Province; Dominican Srs. of Great Bend, KS; Dominican Srs.
of Springfield Illinois; Ethical Funds; School Srs. of Notre Dame of St. Louis;
Sinsinawa Dominicans; Society of Jesus -- Canada Province; Society of Jesus --
Chicago Province; Society of Jesus -- Maryland Conference; Society of Jesus --
Missouri Province; Society of Jesus -- New Orleans Province; Society of Jesus
-- New York Province; Society of Jesus -- Oregon Province; Society of Jesus --
Wisconsin Province; Srs. of Charity of St. Elizabeth, NJ; Srs. of St. Dominic
of Caldwell, NJ; Srs. of St. Francis of Philadelphia; Srs. of St.
Francis-Dubuque, Iowa