Disclose Climate Data
2004 – Exxon Mobil
Corporation
Whereas:
Corporations have a social
responsibility to create value for shareholders and benefits for society. However, companies acting to maximize
shareholder value may in the course of business impose costs on the public,
including environmental degradation and climate change. It is in the long-term interest of society
to minimize these "externalities," partly because they may hamper
economic growth.
Government is responsible for
creating standards for business conduct that will ensure respect for the
environment and the public welfare. It
is in the interest of shareholders for companies to act within a legal and
regulatory framework that is consistent, predictable and effective.
Effective policymaking requires
the best possible information. Without
the cooperation of business, policymakers may lack crucial information that may
impact the quality of regulation.
Companies have a responsibility to be as transparent as possible in
providing information to the public and the government.
Whereas:
The Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (IPCC), the international body of experts charged with climate
change research, stated in its 2001 Third Assessment Report:
"There is new and stronger
evidence that most of the warming observed over the last 50 years is
attributable to human activity...Human influences will continue to change
atmospheric composition throughout the 21st century."
The study describes climate
impacts, such as higher global temperatures and increased precipitation, as
"very likely."
The National Academy of
Sciences (NAS) concurs:
"The degree of confidence
in the IPCC assessment is higher today than it was 10, or even five years
ago...there is general agreement that the observed warming is real and
particularly strong within the past 20 years."
Exxon Mobil has funded
scientific studies and made public statements regarding the science of climate
change that appear to conflict with these conclusions. According to the June 2002 edition of Exxon
Mobil Perspectives:
"There continue to be
substantial and well-documented gaps in climate science. These gaps limit scientists' ability to
assess the extent of any human influence on climate..."
Whereas:
A worldwide movement towards
greater regulation to mitigate climate change has resulted from IPCC
reports. Consistent with its own
position, Exxon Mobil opposes most such regulation. Yet, it has not released primary research or an analysis of data
supporting its conclusions. The lack of
such information prevents shareholders, policymakers, and the public from being
able to make decisions based on the facts the company claims to have.
Resolved: That, by the 2005 annual shareholder
meeting, the Board of Directors make available to shareholders all research
data relevant to ExxonMobil's stated position on the science of climate change,
omitting proprietary information and at reasonable cost.
Supporting Statement
These data should:
Explain the specific
differences between the company's position and that of the IPCC and NAS.
Describe company claims about
'gaps in climate science.'
Project the estimated costs of
mitigating climate change compared to the costs of failing to do so.
Discuss all relevant peer
reviewed research data leading to the company's conclusions, including data
that do not support the company's position.
Sponsors:
Lead:
Christian Brothers Investment Services, Mr. John K. Wilson Social Research
Coordinator; Congregation of the Passion-East; Maryknoll
Fathers and Brothers; Mercy Investment Program (was Mercy Consolidated Asset
Management Program); Srs. of the Humility of Mary