Investors Challenge Pharmaceutical
Companies to Examine
Drug Pricing Practices
CONTACT: Sr. Susan Vickers (415-438-5511); or Ms. Margaret Weber (517-266-3521 or 313-272-5820)
New York, December 12, 2002 - Calling current prescription drug
situations in the U.S. a "national crisis," 23 institutional
investors belonging to Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility
(ICCR), are challenging pharmaceutical companies on two critical
issues: payments and incentives made to pharmaceutical purchasers,
and extensions of expiring prescription drugs patents. "Financial
incentives to influence drug selection, and attempts to prolong
patents and exclude generic drugs, are two reasons why pharmaceuticals
are so expensive," explained Sr. Susan Vickers of Catholic
Healthcare West, "and the financial burden falls hardest on
the un-insured and under-insured."
Since 1993 ICCR has pressed pharmaceutical companies to make prescription
drugs more available and affordable to all. This year Johnson &
Johnson, Pfizer, Schering-Plough and Wyeth have received shareholder
proposals asking for transparency on payments made to doctors, pharmacy
benefit managers and other pharmaceutical purchasers in order to
influence the selection of particular drugs. The companies are also
being asked to report on plans to implement recently promulgated
Department of Health & Human Services Guidelines for preventing
and reducing fraud and abuse in Federal healthcare programs. "The
DHHS is concerned that marketing practices could drive up costs
for Medicare and Medicaid," said Ms. Margaret Weber, representative
of the Dominican Sisters of Adrian, Michigan.
Shareholders have also asked Abbott, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Eli Lilly
and Merck to develop and report on ethical criteria for the extension
of patents. There has been much publicity during the past year about
certain strategies used by companies to extend patents on brand
name prescription drugs, including changing some small aspect, or
suing or paying generic companies to not market their pharmaceuticals.
The Federal Trade Commission chairperson has criticized these as
"gaming the patent system."
Sponsors of the shareholder resolutions are members of ICCR, an
association of 275 institutional investors, who use their portfolios,
estimated $110 billion, to hold companies socially and environmentally
responsible. Sponsors include major religiously-affiliated healthcare
corporations serving thousands of patients, a foundation and several
religious congregations throughout the United States. "Pharmaceuticals
often make the difference between life and death," said Ms.
Weber. "As shareholders, we believe that company policies and
practices can make these medicines more or less accessible to those
requiring them."